Serial Killer Speakeasy – Sheboygan

Serial Killer Speakeasy brings a very different kind of true crime experience to Wisconsin. This 90-minute immersive theatrical cocktail experience puts four infamous killers at the center of the story: Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, John Wayne Gacy and Ed Gein. Rather than simply watching a true-crime presentation, guests experience live performances told through the perspectives of the killers, with each case paired with its own themed cocktail.

The evening unfolds as four case files and four drinks: Bundy is paired with the “Friendly Stranger,” Dahmer with “Apartment Two One Three,” Gacy with “Killer Clowns,” and Gein with “Gein’s Cauldron.” The experience creates an intimate setting for the combination of live theater, dark history and craft cocktails. General admission includes the performance and four cocktails, while VIP tickets add front-row seating.

Serial Killer Speakeasy is a 21+ event, and valid ID is required. Mocktails are available by request. For Wisconsin true crime fans, it is an unusual alternative to the typical haunted attraction or Halloween event: part theatrical performance, part cocktail tasting and part immersive journey into some of America’s most notorious criminal cases.